Ruben Amorim’s start as Manchester United manager has been challenging, with the team languishing in 14th place in the Premier League. Despite this, Andy Mitten, founder of the United We Stand fanzine, reports that Amorim still enjoys the support of most players and fans. His openness and enthusiasm have been welcomed by many within the squad. However, there are indications that certain players, particularly those on the fringes of the first team—such as Marcus Rashford, Antony, Christian Eriksen, Casemiro, Joshua Zirkzee, and Victor Lindelöf—may not share this sentiment.
Calls for Amorim’s dismissal are tempered by the club’s faith in his long-term vision. Nonetheless, Andy Mitten acknowledges that no manager at a club the size of Manchester United can afford continuous poor results.
Amorim has remained resolute in his tactical philosophy, sticking with a three-at-the-back formation despite its struggles. Addressing criticism, he explained:
“If I change my approach all the time, it’s going to get even worse. I understand the difficulties players face adapting to a new system after two years of playing another way. But I have to sell my idea. I don’t have another one.”
The manager admitted that the team’s struggles were apparent in their most recent performances, where moments of individual brilliance rather than structured play seemed to drive scoring opportunities.
Pundit Criticism and Tactical Concerns:
Pundits have begun to scrutinize Amorim’s decisions. Writing for the Daily Mail, Danny Murphy criticized Amorim’s tactics during a match against Newcastle, describing it as “football suicide.” Murphy pointed out the risks of deploying a two-player midfield against a more athletic Newcastle side, which quickly resulted in United falling 2-0 behind.
Murphy argued that unless Amorim adjusts his system or personnel, the team’s poor form will continue:
“Performances and results aren’t going to change unless there’s a tactical shift. It’s particularly worrying as United sit down in 14th place.”
Outlook:
While Amorim still has the support of many players and fans, his position appears increasingly precarious. Without an improvement in results, the manager may face mounting pressure to adapt his approach—or risk being replaced.
